|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Members of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Teimuraz Tughushi and Irine Imerlishvili Regarding the Judgment №2/1/702 dated June 14, 2024, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do2/1/702
|
14 June 2024
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Members of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Giorgi Tevdorashvili and Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze Regarding the Judgment №1/2/1753 dated June 6, 2024, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do1/2/1753
|
6 June 2024
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
|
N(N)LE "Georgian Young Lawyers’ Association" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1825
|
17 June 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze.
|
|
|
NNLE "Young Barristers" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N2/2/1344
|
14 June 2024
|
Judgment
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
|
Konstantine Labartkava, Malkhaz Nozadze and Irakli Gigolashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N2/1/702
|
14 June 2024
|
Judgment
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
|
Aslanbek Dadaev v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/3/1806
|
6 June 2024
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Shalva Javakhia v. the Parliament of Georgia and the Minister of Justice of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/2/1767
|
6 June 2024
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
|
Roman Zantaraia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1824
|
11 June 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Teimuraz Tughushi.
|
|
|
Emzar Kvitsiani, Eter Chkhetiani-Ansiani, Maia Ansiani and Iagor Ansiani v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N3/2/1400
|
7 June 2024
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold partially
|
|
Giorgi Ugulava, Nugzar Kaishauri, Davit Tsipuria, Gizo Ghlonti, Giorgi Lobzhanidze, Archil Alavidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N3/1/740,764
|
7 June 2024
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/2/1753
|
6 June 2024
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
|
№1822 Constitutional Complaint
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1822
|
5 June 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
|
|
№1823 Constitutional Complaint
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1823
|
5 June 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Eva Gotsiridze.
|
|
|
Amicus Curiae: Authors - Ana Pirtskhalashvili, Vaja Menabde, Luka Shermadini, Jemal Bortsvadze, Givi Bluashvili, Nikoloz Mindadze
|
amicus curiae
|
ac1773
|
31 May 2024
|
amicus curiae
|
,
.
|
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1821
|
30 May 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Vasil Roinishvili.
|
|
|
Giorgi Tsibadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/1/1815
|
15 May 2024
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
|
Mindia Vasakmadze v. the Minister of Justice of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1820
|
16 May 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
|
Marine Kapanadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/1/1618
|
15 May 2024
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
|
Mariam Beridze v. the LEPL "Georgian Bar Association"
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/14/1757
|
19 April 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Tina Bochorishvili and Iuri Dvalishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/13/1738
|
19 April 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/12/1678, 1679
|
19 April 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
|
Mariam Gogvadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/11/1664
|
19 April 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
|
Tina Bochorishvili and Iuri Dvalishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/5/1738
|
18 April 2024
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
|
Giorgi Ergemlidze v. the Parliament of Georgia and the Minister of Justice of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1819
|
2 May 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
|
|
Constitutional Submission of Zestaphoni District Court
|
Constitutional Referance
|
N1818
|
1 May 2024
|
Constitutional Referance
|
Irine Imerlishvili.
|
|
|
Khvicha Kirmizashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1817
|
30 April 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze.
|
|
|
Akaki Chikobava and Giorgi Khasaia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1814
|
23 April 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Teimuraz Tughushi.
|
|
|
LTD "Georgian Forestry Industrial Company" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1816
|
23 April 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Irine Imerlishvili.
|
|
|
Giorgi Tsibadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1815
|
23 April 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
|
|
Giorgi Sulkhanishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/10/1812
|
29 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Zurab Saghinadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/9/1805
|
29 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
|
Nika Sabashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/8/1783
|
29 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, The case was partially terminated, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Giorgi Zakareishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/7/1761
|
29 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Gela Nioradze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/6/1760
|
29 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, The case was partially terminated, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Giorgi Gigauri v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/5/1746
|
29 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
|
Grigol Dochia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/4/1744
|
29 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
№1813 Constitutional Complaint
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1813
|
21 March 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Eva Gotsiridze.
|
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia and the Government of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/3/1773
|
1 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
Giorgi Arobelidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/2/1726
|
1 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Aleksandre Kobaidze and Miranda Shalamberidze v. Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/1/1717
|
1 March 2024
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
LLC Sanapiro-Investment Group v. Tbilisi City Municipal Assembly
|
Ruling
|
N2/4/1766
|
1 March 2024
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
|
David Ananidze v. the Government of the Autonomous Republic of Adjara
|
Ruling
|
N2/3/1672
|
1 March 2024
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: unauthorized subject
|
|
Inomjon Buvamirzaev v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/2/1661
|
1 March 2024
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
|
Artur Muradiani v. the Minister of Internal Affairs of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/1/1501
|
1 March 2024
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
The case was terminated, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of subsidiarity
|
|
Ana Dolidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N3/9/1362
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
|
Giorgi Sulkhanishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1812
|
20 February 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
|
|
Aitaj Khalilova, Ramida Sarieva, Baniamin Kasimovi and others (7 complainants) v. The Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1811
|
13 February 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Vasil Roinishvili.
|
|
|
"LTD Lazieri" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1810
|
6 February 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
|
|
amicus curiae: Author - LTD "Free university of Tbilisi"
|
amicus curiae
|
ac1693
|
1 February 2024
|
amicus curiae
|
,
.
|
|
|
Natalia Peradze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1809
|
31 January 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze.
|
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1808
|
12 January 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Irine Imerlishvili.
|
|
|
Barish Inani v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1807
|
11 January 2024
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
|
|
"LTD Network of Information Centers" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/6/1801
|
15 December 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
Nikoloz Tomasiani v. the Parliament of Georgia and the Minister of Justice of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/5/1792
|
15 December 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Ana Dolidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/4/1362
|
15 December 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
|
Saba Qutelia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/3/1295
|
15 December 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, The case was partially terminated
|
|
David Gamkrelidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N3/8/1613
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Akaki Tsereteli v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N3/7/1286
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: unauthorized subject
|
|
Tamar Tediashvili, Mikheil Chitadze, Levan Alapishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N3/6/1252
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, The case was partially terminated, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Ekaterine Kiknadze v. Ministry of Culture, Sport and Youth of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/35/1793
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of subsidiarity
|
|
Lasha Shukakidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/34/1787
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Revaz Dokvadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/33/1785
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
|
Irakli Dokvadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/32/1780
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: unauthorized subject, Was not admitted for consideration on merits
|
|
Davit Nebieridze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/31/1768
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Irakli Margvelashvili and Vakhtang Chelidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/30/1764
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
Ekaterine Kiknadze v. Ministry of Culture, Sport and Youth of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/29/1714
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of subsidiarity
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/28/1632
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
|
"LTD Epitsentri" v. the Government of Georgia and the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/27/1570
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Elphrida Rekhviashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/26/1359
|
15 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
|
Aslanbek Dadaev v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1806
|
27 December 2023
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Members of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Irine Imerlishvili and Teimuraz Tughushi Regarding the Judgment №3/5/1502,1503 dated 15 December 2023 of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do3/5/1502,1503
|
15 December 2023
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze Regarding the Judgment №3/5/1502,1503 dated 15 December 2023 of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do3/5/1502,1503
|
15 December 2023
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
|
Marine Kapanadze and Vasil Zhizhiashvili v. the Chairman of the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/9/1800
|
14 December 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Giorgi Kikabidze and Genadi Kvachakhia v. the Parliament of Georgia and Chairman of the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/8/1786
|
14 December 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/7/1753
|
14 December 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili,
Eva Gotsiridze.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia and the Minister of Justice of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/6/1748
|
14 December 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
Gogi Gvidiani v the Parliament and the Georgian Bar Association
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/5/1671
|
14 December 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Tatia Nikolashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/32/1791
|
14 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
Giorgi Okropiridze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/31/1765
|
14 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
Davit Malania v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/30/1756
|
14 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
Giorgi Kemularia, Nino Morgoshia, Veriko Siria and others (8 members) v. The Parliament of Georgia and Minister of Culture, Sport and Youth of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/29/1729
|
14 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
|
Tamari Menabdishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/28/1669
|
14 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
|
Jemal Dumbadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/27/1443
|
14 December 2023
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
|
Zaur Shermazanashvili and Tornike Artkmeladze v. the President of Georgia and the Government of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N3/5/1502,1503
|
15 December 2023
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold partially, The case was partially terminated
|
|
"LTD Network of Information Centers" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N3/4/1483
|
15 December 2023
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
|
Zurab Saghinadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1805
|
15 December 2023
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N3/3/1635
|
14 December 2023
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
|
Political Union of the Citizens "Alliance of Patriots of Georgia" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N3/2/853
|
14 December 2023
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
|
Nikoloz Akofovi v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N2/8/1444
|
22 November 2023
|
Judgment
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
|
David Jaoshvili v. the Minister of Internal Affairs of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/8/1769
|
27 October 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Giorgi Gotsadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/7/1532
|
27 October 2023
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
|
LTD Salkhino v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/25/1686
|
27 October 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
The Concurring Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Teimuraz Tugushi Regarding the Ruling №2/24/1682 dated October 27, 2023, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Concurring Opinion
|
co2/24/1682
|
27 October 2023
|
Concurring Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
|
Giorgi Tsaadze v. Georgian National Energy and Water Supply Regulatory Commission
|
Ruling
|
N2/24/1682
|
27 October 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of jurisdiction
|
|
The Concurring Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Teimuraz Tugushi Regarding the Ruling №2/23/1652 dated October 27, 2023, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Concurring Opinion
|
co2/23/1652
|
27 October 2023
|
Concurring Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
|
Giorgi Tsaadze v. Georgian National Energy and Water Supply Regulatory Commission
|
Ruling
|
N2/23/1652
|
27 October 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, The case was partially terminated, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
|
The Concurring Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Teimuraz Tugushi Regarding the Ruling №2/22/1634 dated October 27, 2023, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Concurring Opinion
|
co2/22/1634
|
27 October 2023
|
Concurring Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
|
Giorgi Tsaadze v. Georgian National Energy and Water Supply Regulatory Commission
|
Ruling
|
N2/22/1634
|
27 October 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
|
Giorgi Gogiashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/21/1579
|
27 October 2023
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
|
Ekaterine Pipia v. the Parliament of Georgia and Minister of Education and Science of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N2/7/1528
|
10 November 2023
|
Judgment
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|