The Dissenting Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze Regarding the Judgment №1/5/1472 dated June 17, 2022, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do1/5/1472
|
17 June 2022
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze Regarding the Judgment №1/4/1464 dated June 17, 2022, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do1/4/1464
|
17 June 2022
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
the Government of Georgia v. the President of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/1-1/1711
|
24 June 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili,
,
.
|
The Plenum admitted the complaint for the consideration on merits
|
Constitutional Submissions of Tetritskaro District Court on Constitutionality of the first sentence of paragraph 6 of article 200 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N3/5/1341,1660
|
24 June 2022
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1-3/1/1635
|
17 June 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
The case was referred to the Plenum for consideration
|
Albert Nurbegiani v. the Government of Georgia and the President of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/13/1704
|
16 June 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of jurisdiction
|
Badri Khorava v. the President of the National Bank of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/12/1702
|
16 June 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: unauthorized subject
|
Paata Nozadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/11/1667
|
16 June 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
Hovhannes Sardaryan v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/10/1574
|
16 June 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
Nugzar Kobakhidze v. the Parliament of Georgia and Tbilisi City Municipal Assembly
|
Ruling
|
N1/9/1477
|
16 June 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of jurisdiction, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of subsidiarity
|
Natalia Pheradze and Konstantine Guruli v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/8/1353
|
16 June 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze Regarding the Judgment №1/3/1377 dated June 17, 2022, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do1/3/1377
|
17 June 2022
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
Nikoloz Lomidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/5/1472
|
17 June 2022
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
Mikheil Khaindrava v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/4/1464
|
17 June 2022
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
Dimitri Ghonghadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/3/1377
|
17 June 2022
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
Shalva Natelashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/4/1688
|
16 June 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
Kalinka Gedenidze, Tamar Geliashvili, Daiana Dartsimelia, Irakli Tchelidze and Salome Rtveliashvili v. the Government of Georgia and the Minister of Education and Science of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/7/1657
|
20 May 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
Natela Bragvadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1709
|
27 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Zviad Devdariani v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1708
|
27 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Matsatso Tepnadze v. the Government of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/6/1608
|
20 May 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Minister of Justice of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/3/1676
|
20 May 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
Nona Kenkadze and Kakhaber Dzagania v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1707
|
23 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
'British American Tobacco Georgia Limited' v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/2/876
|
20 May 2022
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
Nugzari Oziashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1706
|
20 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Kldiashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/4/1518
|
11 May 2022
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the issue has already been adjudicated
|
Levan Alapishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/3/1488
|
11 May 2022
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
Avtandil Metreveli v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/2/1479
|
11 May 2022
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the issue has already been adjudicated
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Government of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1705
|
17 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Davit Gugeshashvili and Davit Chachua v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1703
|
16 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Albert Nurbegiani v. the Government of Georgia and the President of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1704
|
16 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Badri Khorava v. the President of the National Bank of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1702
|
11 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1698
|
6 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Minister of Internally Displaced Persons from the Occupied Territories, Labour, Health and Social Affairs of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1701
|
6 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Labadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1699
|
6 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1700
|
6 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Lasha Shukakidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1697
|
3 May 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Constitutional Submission of Tetritskaro District Court on Constitutionality of the second sentence of paragraph 3 of article 7 of Organic Law of Georgia "on General Courts" and the second sentence of paragraph 2 of article 19 of Organic Law of Georgia "on The Constitutional Court of Georgia"
|
Judgment
|
N3/4/1648
|
21 April 2022
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
Constitutional Submission of Tbilisi City Court on Constitutionality of normative content of section 3 of article 260 of the Criminal Code of Georgia under which imprisonment may be imposed as a punishment for repeatedly illegal purchase and storage of narcotic substance - Cannabis resin (0,1315 grams) for personal consumption
|
Judgment
|
N3/3/1387
|
21 April 2022
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
Giorgi Labadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N3/2/1277
|
21 April 2022
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
Constitutional Submissions of Bolnisi District Court on Constitutionality of normative content of section 1 of article 262 of the Criminal Code of Georgia under which imprisonment may be imposed as a punishment for illegal import of narcotic substance – dried Marijuana (6,4, grams, 6,7 grams and 9,68 grams) for personal consumption
|
Judgment
|
N3/1/1239,1642,1674
|
21 April 2022
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
Davit Nebieridze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1696
|
21 April 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Mikheil Kareli and Ekaterine Kareli v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1695
|
19 April 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
NNLE "Social Justice Center" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1694
|
18 April 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/2/1681
|
13 April 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
Irakli Kacharava v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/5/1599
|
13 April 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of jurisdiction
|
"LTD Georgian Airways" v. the Parliament of Georgia and the Minister of Economy and Sustainable Development of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/4/1368
|
13 April 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
Levan Darsalia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N2/2/1506
|
13 April 2022
|
Judgment
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
Eka Areshidze, Ketevan Meskhishvili, Madona Maisuradze, Mamuka Tsiklauri and Tamar Khazhomia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1693
|
11 April 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Goroshidze and Indiko Abashidze v. the Parliament of Georgia, LEPL "Academic Council of Ivane Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University" and the Minister of Education And Science of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1691
|
1 April 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Goderdzi Gordeziani and LEPL "Evangelical-Baptist Church of Georgia" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1690
|
29 March 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
amicus curiae: Author - N(N)LE "Social Justice Center"
|
amicus curiae
|
ac1673
|
17 March 2022
|
amicus curiae
|
,
.
|
|
Aleksandre Akhaladze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1689
|
16 March 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Shalva Natelashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1688
|
11 March 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
"LTD Lawyer's Office Legal Rights Georgia” v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/1/1553
|
23 February 2022
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of jurisdiction
|
Constitutional Submission of Bolnisi District Court on Constitutionality of normative content of section 1 of article 262 of the Criminal Code of Georgia under which imprisonment may be imposed as a punishment for illegal import of narcotic substance – dried Marijuana (6,4 grams) for personal consumption
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/5/1674
|
23 February 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
Constitutional Submission of Tetritskaro District Court on Constitutionality of the first sentence of paragraph 6 of Article 200 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/4/1660
|
23 February 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
Constitutional Submission of the Tetritskaro District Court on Constitutionality of the wording „If the grounds for suspension specified in paragraph 2 of this article no longer exist, a court hearing ... shall be ... resumed“ of section 4 of Article 167 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Georgia, the second sentence of paragraph 3 of Article 7 of the Organic Law of Georgia "on General Courts" and the second sentence of paragraph 2 of Article 19 of the Organic Law of Georgia "on the Constitutional Court of Georgia"
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/3/1648
|
23 February 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially
|
Constitutional Submission of Bolnisi District Court on Constitutionality of normative content of section 1 of article 262 of the Criminal Code of Georgia under which imprisonment may be imposed as a punishment for illegal import of narcotic substance – dried Marijuana (9,68 grams) for personal consumption
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/2/1642
|
23 February 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
Constitutional Submission of Tbilisi City Court on Constitutionality of normative content of section 3 of article 260 of the Criminal Code of Georgia under which imprisonment may be imposed as a punishment for repeatedly illegal purchase and storage of narcotic substance - Cannabis resin (0,1315 grams) for personal consumption
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/1/1387
|
23 February 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Teimuraz Tughushi Regarding the Ruling №3/1/1681 dated February 23, 2022, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do3/1/1681
|
23 February 2022
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
Teimuraz Lomidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/3/1646
|
28 February 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
Akaki Toidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/2/1309
|
28 February 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
Akaki Toidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/1/1288
|
28 February 2022
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
Londa Toloraia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/1/1673
|
28 February 2022
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
Giorgi Mikeladze v. the Parliament of Georgia and LEPL - the High School of Justice
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1687
|
28 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Otar Marshava and Mikheil Nozadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N2/1/1434,1466
|
25 February 2022
|
Judgment
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N3/1/1681
|
23 February 2022
|
Ruling
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, The case was referred to the Chamber for consideration, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
amicus curiae: Author - NNLE "Georgian Democracy Initiative"
|
amicus curiae
|
ac1673
|
24 February 2022
|
amicus curiae
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Lashkhi v. the Government of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/1/1558
|
23 February 2022
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
N(N)LE "Association of Educational Guardians" and Maka Giorgadze v. the Government of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1685
|
21 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
'LTD Salkhino' v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1686
|
21 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Mikheil Kareli v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1683
|
17 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Government of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1684
|
17 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Tsaadze v. the Georgian National Energy and Water Supply Regulatory Commission
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1682
|
9 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1681
|
8 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1675
|
7 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1680
|
7 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1678
|
7 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1679
|
7 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Minister of Justice of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1676
|
7 February 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Constitutional Submission of Bolnisi District Court on Constitutionality of normative content of section 1 of article 262 of the Criminal Code of Georgia under which imprisonment may be imposed as a punishment for illegal import of narcotic substance – dried Marijuana (6,4 grams) for personal consumption
|
Constitutional Referance
|
N1674
|
1 February 2022
|
Constitutional Referance
|
,
.
|
|
Londa Toloraia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1673
|
28 January 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Gogi Gvidiani v. the Parliament of Georgia and the LEPL "Georgian Bar Association"
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1671
|
27 January 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
David Ananidze v. the Government of the Autonomous Republic of Adjara
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1672
|
27 January 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
,
.
|
|
Tamari Menabdishvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1669
|
11 January 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Teimuraz Lomidze and Giorgi Beridze v. the Government of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1670
|
11 January 2022
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Constitutional Submission of Tetritskaro District Court on Constitutionality of the second sentence of paragraph 20 of article 3, the third sentence of paragraph 2 of article 25, paragraph 1 and 2, the first sentence of paragraph 5 and the first sentence of paragraph 7 of article 48 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N3/2/1478
|
28 December 2021
|
Judgment
|
Merab Turava,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold partially
|
Elga Maisuradze, Irma Ginturi and Leri Todadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/6/1320
|
28 December 2021
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
N(N)LE “Georgian Muslims Union”, LEPL “Apostolic Administration of the Latin Catholics of Caucasus”, LEPL “The Highest Administration of all Muslims in Georgia”, LEPL “Evangelical-Baptist Church of Georgia”, N(N)LE “Union of Georgian Jews”, LEPL “Religious Society of Friends – Quakers" and LEPL “Holy Church of Open Christians in Georgia” v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/16/1640
|
16 December 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/15/1628
|
16 December 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
Marine Kapanadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/14/1618
|
16 December 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/13/1603
|
16 December 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/12/1602
|
16 December 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
Karl Reinhold Augustsson v. the Government of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/22/1650
|
16 December 2021
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
Tengiz Meskhi v. the Minister of Internally Displaced Persons from the Occupied Territories, Labour, Health and Social Affairs of Georgia and the Minister of Internal Affairs of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/21/1626
|
16 December 2021
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze Regarding the Ruling №1/20/1614 dated December 16, 2021, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do1/20/1614
|
16 December 2021
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
Zviad Gogiashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/20/1614
|
16 December 2021
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the issue has already been adjudicated
|
LTD "Em.ji. Aliansi" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/19/1610
|
16 December 2021
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
Giorgi Gvazava, Ruslan Avaliani, Gocha Grigoriantsi and others (30 complainants) v. the Parliament of Georgia and the Government of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N1/18/1584
|
16 December 2021
|
Ruling
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, The case was partially terminated, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
Paata Nozadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1667
|
28 December 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Nika Nozadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1668
|
28 December 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Izolda Shanidze v. LEPL National Bureau of Enforcement
|
Ruling
|
N2/16/1617
|
10 December 2021
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of jurisdiction
|
Elene Gegeshidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/15/1615
|
10 December 2021
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
N(N)LE Political Union of Citizens "Georgian Labour Party" v. the Government of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/14/1612
|
10 December 2021
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of jurisdiction
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Minister of Justice of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/13/1460
|
10 December 2021
|
Ruling
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
Shio Surmanidze v. the Government of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/12/1621
|
10 December 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Government of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/11/1604
|
10 December 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
Archil Morbedadze and Amalia Badaliani v. the Minister of Education And Science of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/10/1559
|
10 December 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
Mikheil Samnidze v. the Government of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/5/1499
|
16 December 2021
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was not uphold
|
Vasil Zhizhiashvili and George Putkaradze v. the Minister of Internal Affairs of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1666
|
16 December 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Lasha Shukakidze v. the Government of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1665
|
8 December 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Tsaadze v. the Georgian National Energy and Water Supply Regulatory Commission
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1663
|
8 December 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Mariam Gogvadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1664
|
8 December 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Maia Gaikharashvili v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1662
|
1 December 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N1/11/1605
|
18 November 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
Citizen of Uzbekistan Inomjon Buvamirzaev v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1661
|
24 November 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Constitutional Submission of the Tetritskaro District Court on Constitutionality of section 6 of Article 200 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Georgia
|
Constitutional Referance
|
N1660
|
24 November 2021
|
Constitutional Referance
|
,
.
|
|
Lana Mzarelua v. Tbilisi City Municipal Assembly
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1659
|
16 November 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
N(N)LE Political Union of the Citizens "United National Movement", N(N)LE "Apriori" and N(N)LE "Law Enforcement Reform Center" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N3/3/1297
|
21 October 2021
|
Ruling
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
The case was terminated
|
Aleksandre Kobaidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1658
|
4 November 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Kalinka Gedenidze, Tamar Geliashvili, Daiana Dartsimelia, Irakli Tchelidze and Salome Rtveliashvili v. the Government of Georgia and Minister of Education and Science of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1657
|
3 November 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Sandro Urushadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1656
|
3 November 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Tengiz Orjonikidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1655
|
2 November 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Members of the Constitutional Court of Georgia - Teimuraz Tughushi and Irine Imerlishvili Regarding the Ruling №3/2/1647 dated October 21, 2021, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do3/2/1647
|
21 October 2021
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Eva Gotsiridze Regarding the Ruling №3/2/1647 dated October 21, 2021, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do3/2/1647
|
21 October 2021
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
The Dissenting Opinion of the Member of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze Regarding the Ruling №3/2/1647 dated October 21, 2021, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do3/2/1647
|
21 October 2021
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
Political Union of Citizens "European Georgia - Movement for Liberty", Nino Todria, Marta Kardava, Nino Ordenidze and others (12 complainants) v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N3/2/1647
|
21 October 2021
|
Ruling
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Disputed provision was declared unconstitutional on the preliminary hearing, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: unauthorized subject
|
Aleksandre Kobaidze and Miranda Shalamberidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1654
|
18 October 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Qeburia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1653
|
7 October 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Tsaadze v. the Georgian National Energy and Water Supply Regulatory Commission
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1652
|
6 October 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Vakhtang Menabde, Vasil Zhizhiashvili, Gvantsa Sakanelashvili and Nona Kurdovanidze v. the Parliament of Georgia and N20 Rustavi District Election Commission
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1651
|
29 September 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Karl Reinhold Augustsson v. the Government of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1650
|
24 September 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Nana Shervashidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1649
|
24 September 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Tsertsvadze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Judgment
|
N1/4/1330
|
23 September 2021
|
Judgment
|
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Vasil Roinishvili,
Giorgi Tevdorashvili.
|
Complaint was uphold
|
amicus curiae: Author - LTD "Free University of Tbilisi"
|
amicus curiae
|
ac1537
|
14 September 2021
|
amicus curiae
|
,
.
|
|
Constitutional Submission of the Tetritskaro District Court on Constitutionality of section 4 of Article 167 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Georgia, the second sentence of paragraph 3 of Article 7 of the Organic Law of Georgia "on General Courts" and the second sentence of paragraph 2 of Article 19 of the Organic Law of Georgia "on the Constitutional Court of Georgia"
|
Constitutional Referance
|
N1648
|
8 September 2021
|
Constitutional Referance
|
,
.
|
|
amicus curiae: Author - Public Defender of Georgia
|
amicus curiae
|
ac1636
|
31 August 2021
|
amicus curiae
|
,
.
|
|
Political Union of Citizens "Alliance of Patriots of Georgia" v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/6/1636
|
4 August 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: unauthorized subject
|
Teimuraz Lomidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1646
|
17 August 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Political Union of Citizens "European Georgia - Movement for Liberty", Nino Todria, Marta Kardava, Nino Ordenidze and others (12 complainants) v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1647
|
17 August 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
Ruslan Gvaradze v. the Government of Georgia
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
N1645
|
13 August 2021
|
Constitutional Complaint
|
,
.
|
|
The Dissent Opinion of the Members of the Constitutional Court of Georgia Teimuraz Tughushi, Irine Imerlishvili and Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze Regarding the Recording Notice №3/1-3/1264 dated July 23, 2021, of the Constitutional Court of Georgia
|
Dissent Opinion
|
do3/1-3/1264
|
23 July 2021
|
Dissent Opinion
|
,
.
|
|
Giorgi Mamaladze, Giorgi Phantsulaia and Mia Zoidze v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N3/1-3/1264
|
23 July 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Merab Turava,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Giorgi Kverenchkhiladze,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze,
Eva Gotsiridze,
Khvicha Kikilashvili,
Vasil Roinishvili.
|
The Plenum admitted the complaint for the consideration on merits
|
Giorgi Jobava v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/9/1600
|
15 July 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Tamaz Tsabutashvili,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
"Concern Teka" LLC v. the Ministry of Justice of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/12/1575
|
15 July 2021
|
Ruling
|
Tamaz Tsabutashvili,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: the problem of the relation with the Constitutional provision
|
Giorgi Mikeladze v. the Parliament of Georgia and the Government of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/8/1564
|
15 July 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Tamaz Tsabutashvili,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
LTD "Lawyer’s office Legal Rights Georgia” v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/11/1557
|
15 July 2021
|
Ruling
|
Tamaz Tsabutashvili,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: other problem of reasoning
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. Tbilisi City Municipal Assembly
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/7/1545
|
15 July 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Tamaz Tsabutashvili,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits partially, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Recording Notice
|
N2/6/1542
|
15 July 2021
|
Recording Notice
|
Tamaz Tsabutashvili,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
Admitted for consideration on merits
|
The Public Defender of Georgia v. the Parliament of Georgia
|
Ruling
|
N2/10/1540
|
15 July 2021
|
Ruling
|
Tamaz Tsabutashvili,
Irine Imerlishvili,
Teimuraz Tughushi,
Manana Kobakhidze.
|
Was not admitted for consideration on merits, Basis of inadmissibility for consideration on merits: content-wise problem of the disputed provision
|